Quick answer: CarComplaints.com names the 2014 Porsche Cayman as the worst model year, but only 9 complaints are on file, so the signal is weak. Check 2006 cars for shifter cable failure and 2021 GT4 and GTS 4.0 cars for the connecting rod recall. Judge any Cayman by records and inspection.
The Porsche Cayman is a popular way to get started with a Porsche coupe. It is a two-seater known for its handling, and it is simple to drive across all generations.
Its center of gravity is lower and closer to the center of the vehicle. According to carcomplaints.com, there aren’t many reported flaws in the Porsche Cayman, but a small pool of complaints also limits what the data can prove.
This article covers the Porsche Cayman years to approach with care, the problems behind them, and how to choose the best individual car.
Porsche Cayman Years to Avoid (List of Years)
According to CarComplaints.com, the Porsche Cayman has a low number of complaints on file. Only 2014 is named as the worst model year. The 2006 and 2021 model years are included below because each has one problem on the site’s top-three worst problems list.
Porsche Cayman Years to Check Most Carefully:
- 2014 Porsche Cayman: named the worst year, with the most complaints
- 2006 Porsche Cayman: broken shifter cable reports
- 2021 Porsche Cayman: connecting rod stop sale and recall on specific versions
The 2014 Porsche Cayman has the most complaints on CarComplaints.com. As checked on November 9, 2026, the 2014 page lists 9 complaints and the 2021 page lists 2.
| Model year | What the data shows | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Named worst year; 9 complaints; top-ranked problem is a PCM that constantly reboots | PCM operation, headliner, door panels |
| 2006 | One problem on the top-three list: broken shifter cable | Shifter feel and engagement in every gear |
| 2021 | 2 complaints; 193 cars recalled across four models | Proof that recall AMA4 was completed on affected versions |
The 2006 model has a costlier repair tied to a broken shifter cable. The car can get stuck in gear, and the shifter goes limp.
A minor number of engine-related issues have been reported.
Should You Avoid These Cayman Years Completely?
No. Treat these years as a reason to inspect more closely, not as an automatic no. CarComplaints has too few Cayman complaints to support a firm ranking, and a single owner report can move a year up the list.
At the same time, no authoritative source declares every Cayman year safe. Use this decision rule:
- Walk away if a seller won’t share the VIN, refuses an inspection, or can’t show that an open safety recall was fixed.
- Negotiate if the problem is known and priced, such as a shifter cable or a PCM fault.
- Keep shopping if the inspection finds an unexplained engine, coolant or oil problem.
What Makes These Porsche Cayman Years Worth Checking?
Here is a closer look at each potential issue and the Cayman models tied to it.
1. Broken Cable Shifter
One 2006 Porsche Cayman owner reported a broken shifter cable that left the car stuck in gear.
The Porsche Cayman is a high-end vehicle, and repairs can cost real money. A sudden failure like this one is especially frustrating.
According to the owner, the shifter suddenly went limp about 1,000 yards from home while shifting from 2nd to 3rd. The car stayed stuck in 2nd gear.
The owner moved the shifter into different gear slots, but the gears did not change.
CarComplaints lists the average mileage for this problem as 34,000 miles, based on very little data. That owner’s car had 34,150 miles. The fix costs about $1,000.

2. Sagging Headliner
The headliner of a 2014 Porsche Cayman was found brushing the top of the owner’s head. It sagged up to 6 inches in the middle. The adhesive failed, and the fabric hung down in the cabin.
This occurred when it was raining. The owner questioned whether the glue was water-soluble, but that has not been confirmed.
The owner also reported that the leather on the door panels was coming away around the windows, which is a separate issue.
3. PCM That Constantly Reboots
CarComplaints’ top-ranked Cayman problem, as checked on November 9, 2026, is a 2014 PCM (Porsche Communication Management, the infotainment unit) that constantly reboots. The site lists an average repair cost of $3,000 at about 11,000 miles.
4. 2021 Stop Sale for Faulty Connecting Rods
Porsche issued a 2021 stop sale tied to faulty connecting rods. It affected the 2021 Cayman GT4, Cayman GTS 4.0, Boxster GTS 4.0 and 718 Spyder.
One owner who bought a 2021 Cayman said the Porsche dealer reported that the car was subject to the stop sale.
That owner said the dealer gave no repair information or timeline at the time. Even though the car was paid in full, the owner could not take possession of it.
The recall announced on March 24, 2021 later set the remedy. Dealers replace the connecting rods or, if needed, the engine, free of charge. Owner letters were mailed on May 21, 2021.
5. Engine Problems
Porsche flat-six engines used in the Cayman have been affected by a connecting rod defect that can break the rod and damage the engine. Porsche said it was unaware of any problems resulting from the faulty connecting rod. It also said all owners who had taken delivery of affected vehicles were notified of the recall.
NHTSA recall 21V200000 (Porsche code AMA4) covers 193 model-year 2021 cars. On those cars, a loosened connecting rod may cause engine damage, a stall or an oil leak, which increases the risk of a crash or fire. On the Cayman engine, misfires can happen at any time. Diagnostics are needed to determine which cylinders are misfiring.
Don’t assume the cause of a weak or misfiring cylinder. Have a technician test the affected cylinder and its related parts before you replace anything or agree on a price.
6. Loss of Coolant
Treat unexplained coolant loss as a serious warning sign on any used Cayman. Cracked cylinder liners are sometimes blamed, but the sources checked for this article do not confirm that as a Cayman pattern.
Watch for a falling coolant level in the expansion tank or an engine that runs hot. Either one needs a diagnosis before you buy.
Continuing to drive an overheating engine can make the damage worse.
7. Oil Leakage
Main seal leaks are sometimes mentioned on the Cayman, but the sources checked do not confirm how common they are. Have a technician find the source of any oil around the engine or the area where it meets the transmission.
Don’t accept “it’s just a dried-out seal” without a diagnosis. Several different faults can leave oil in the same area.
Which 2021 Caymans Were Recalled, and How Do You Check a VIN?
Recall 21V200000 covers the 2021 Cayman GT4 and Cayman GTS 4.0, along with the 718 Spyder and Boxster GTS 4.0. It does not cover every 2021 Cayman.
Enter the car’s VIN in NHTSA’s recall lookup tool, then ask a Porsche dealer to confirm whether AMA4 applies and has been completed. Run the same VIN check on any Cayman year, because this article details only this one recall.
How Do the Cayman Generations Compare?
Cayman shoppers will see four generation codes: 987.1, 987.2, 981 and 718. The complaint data is organized by model year, so it can’t give a reliable generation-by-generation ranking.
CarWhere lists the 981 generation as 2013-2016, with the Cayman version starting in model year 2014. That makes the worst-ranked year the first 981 Cayman year. Still, its top-ranked problem is an infotainment fault, not an engine failure, so the ranking alone doesn’t show that the 981 has a weak engine.
Which Cayman Years Have IMS Bearing or Bore Scoring Problems?
Intermediate shaft (IMS) bearing failure and bore scoring are two engine concerns that early Cayman shoppers commonly ask about. The sources checked for this article do not confirm which years or engines are affected, so no year list is given here.
Don’t rely on a seller’s claim about either one. Ask a Porsche specialist to identify the exact engine, explain its risk, and review any repair records. A bore scope check lets the inspector look inside the cylinders.
Is the 718 Cayman Four-Cylinder Reliable?
There isn’t enough verified data here to give the turbocharged four-cylinder a firm verdict or rank it against the flat-six cars. The 2021 recall lists only the GT4 and GTS 4.0 among Cayman versions, so it says nothing about four-cylinder reliability either way. Use the same records and inspection checks on these cars.
Does the Transmission Type Change Which Cayman to Buy?
The sources checked do not rank manual, Tiptronic and PDK Caymans for reliability, so choose based on how you want to drive. Test the exact car and make sure every gear engages cleanly. On a manual, a limp shifter is a clear warning sign.
Are Porsche Caymans Expensive to Maintain?
Individual repairs can be expensive. CarComplaints lists about $1,000 for the 2006 shifter cable repair and an average of $3,000 for the 2014 PCM problem. Both figures rest on very few reports, so treat them as rough examples and not as typical costs.
No verified cost breakdown by generation was available for this article. Before you buy, ask an independent Porsche shop to quote the work the inspection finds, and subtract any needed repairs from your offer.
How Should You Inspect a Used Cayman Before Buying?
Pay for an independent inspection by a Porsche specialist before you commit. Use this checklist:
- Run the VIN. Look for open recalls before you visit the car.
- Check recall paperwork. On a 2021 GT4 or GTS 4.0, ask for proof that AMA4 was completed.
- Read the service records. Look for regular maintenance and any engine or transmission work.
- Ask for an engine over-rev report. It can show whether the engine has been pushed past its safe rev range.
- Request a bore scope check. Ask the inspector to look at the condition of each cylinder.
- Test the shifter. Try every gear and note any limp or disconnected feel.
- Check fluids and leaks. Look at the coolant level and for oil around the engine and transmission.
- Check the cabin. Watch for PCM reboots, a sagging headliner and loose door panel leather.
Which Porsche Cayman Years are Safe to Buy?
No source checked for this article names one most reliable Cayman year. The safest buy is the individual car with complete records, no open recalls and a clean specialist inspection.
You may see 2009-2012 cars promoted as the best range. The sources checked do not confirm that, so treat it as opinion and don’t pay extra for the model year alone.
A low complaint count is a good sign, but it isn’t proof of reliability. This is especially true of newer model years, which have had less time to build a complaint history. Neglected maintenance can also lead to problems on any Cayman, so service history matters in every year.
Is Porsche Discontinuing the Gas-Powered Cayman?
Yes. As reported on September 4, 2025, Porsche had stopped taking new orders for the gasoline 718 Cayman and Boxster, with production scheduled to end in 2026. The names are set to return on electric models built on the PPE platform.
Conclusion
The 2014 Cayman is the only year CarComplaints names as worst, and the 2006 and 2021 model years each have a specific problem to check. With so few complaints on file, none of these years should be ruled out on the data alone.
Check the VIN, read the records and pay for a specialist inspection. Walk away from any Cayman with an open safety recall that the seller won’t fix, or an engine problem no one can explain.
Related Posts:
- What Year Porsche 911 to Avoid and Why? (Explained)
- Which Porsche 996 Years to Avoid and Why? (Explained)
- Which Porsche 997 Years You Should Avoid and Why?
- Which Porsche Boxster Years to Avoid and Why? (Explained)
- Which Porsche Cayenne Years to Avoid and Why? (Explained)
Porsche Cayman Years to Avoid: FAQ
What is the worst year for the Porsche Cayman?
CarComplaints.com names the 2014 Porsche Cayman as the worst model year. It has only 9 complaints on file as of November 9, 2026, so the signal is weak. Its top-ranked problem is a PCM infotainment unit that constantly reboots, which is not an engine failure. Treat 2014 as a reason to inspect closely.
What happens when a 2006 Porsche Cayman shifter cable breaks?
The car can get stuck in gear, and the shifter goes limp. One 2006 Cayman owner reported this while shifting from 2nd to 3rd, and the car stayed in 2nd. CarComplaints lists a repair cost of about $1,000, based on very little data. Test every gear before buying a 2006 car.
Do owners pay for the 2021 Cayman connecting rod recall repair?
No. Under recall 21V200000, also called AMA4, dealers replace the connecting rods or, if needed, the engine, free of charge. The recall covers 193 model-year 2021 cars, including the Cayman GT4 and Cayman GTS 4.0. If you are buying one of these cars, ask for proof that the work was completed.
Does a low complaint count mean a Cayman year is reliable?
No. A low complaint count is a good sign, but it isn’t proof of reliability. Newer model years have had less time to build a complaint history, and a single owner report can move a year up the list. Service records and a specialist inspection tell you more about an individual car.
What should you do if a used Cayman is losing coolant?
Get a diagnosis before you buy. Unexplained coolant loss is a serious warning sign on any used Cayman. Watch for a falling level in the expansion tank or an engine that runs hot. If an inspection can’t explain the problem, keep shopping. Driving an overheating engine can make the damage worse.
