Which BMW X5 Years to Avoid and Why? (Explained)

Many luxury automobile enthusiasts would never consider purchasing a secondhand vehicle if they were in the market for one. Then there are used automobile buyers who have no desire to own a high-end vehicle.

Is there a demand for pre-owned luxury cars like the BMW X5 if this is the case?

BMW’s X5 premium SUV is a popular choice for buyers. If you’re interested in purchasing a used BMW X5, keep reading. In the table below, I’ve outlined the BMW X5 model years to steer clear of, as well as the ones that are safe to purchase secondhand.

BMW X5 Years to Avoid (List of Years)

Occasionally, you may hear of a car issue that is so frequent in a specific year that you decide to avoid it at all costs. Neither is the BMW X5.

Below are the BMW X5 years that are known to have issues with reliability:

  • 2008 BMW X5
  • 2009 BMW X5
  • 2012 BMW X5
  • 2013 BMW X5
  • 2014 BMW X5

What Makes These BMW X5 Years Worth Avoiding?

It was produced from 1999 to 2006, then from 2006 to 2013 and from 2013 to 2018 for the second and third generation X5s, respectively.

Known as the G05 X5, the fourth and current iteration was launched on June 6, 2018, at the Geneva Motor Show. A plug-in hybrid vehicle will be available on the market by 2020.

Anyone who has ever had a high-end automobile is aware of both the advantages and disadvantages of owning one. Although the BMW X5 is a wonderful car, it has its own set of specific problems.

The following is a comprehensive list of potential issues with the BMW X5, along with reasons to steer clear of them.


According to CarComplaints, the 2008 BMW X5 doesn’t have a lot of issues. Water seeping into the cabin, a broken coolant pump, and a lack of power while driving are the most common issues.

Concern is focused on the SUV’s interior water leakage. Drain tubes were not properly emptied, and water leaked into the electrical system.

Your car’s ability to accelerate and maintain speed should be another thing you keep an eye on when you are driving.


In fact, according to CarComplaints, the 2009 BMW X5 is one of the most trouble-free premium SUVs on the market. Oil leaks and melting brake lights are two of the issues that the vehicle has.

According to several automobile forums, oil leaks are a typical problem with this vehicle. Two oil leaks were reported by one customer, and the dealership claimed that the problem was caused by faulty alternator brackets and timing covers.

This year’s X5 has also been plagued with melting taillights. This is a severe safety issue and causes the warning lights to display on the dashboard.


Consumer Reports gave the 2013 BMW X5 a poor 1 out of 5 dependability rating, making it one of the worst BMW X5 years. There are way too many red flags on the X5’s safety score sheet for it to be considered safe.

The 2013 X5’s fuel system has been plagued by several complaints from owners. Fuel pump failure and even disintegration were reported by one owner, leaving fuel system particles.

Another issue that has been brought up by customers is the need to replace the fuel injection system because of stalling and power loss.

This year’s X5 is no exception to the trend of oil leaks. According to a number of people, their SUV is either consuming too much oil or leaking all over the place, or both.


The BMW X5’s second year isn’t any better. The 2014 BMW X5 received yet another 1 out of 5 rating from Consumer Reports for its dependability.

The 2014 X5 has a lot of complaints from owners on Consumer Reports about its structural integrity. Water seeps from the roof onto the driver’s side floor, according to one customer. Squeaks and rattles have been reported by a number of customers, who feel that this is unacceptable for a premium car of this kind.

Additionally, Consumer Reports gave the suspension, fuel system, minor and main engine, and electric system a 1 out of 5-star rating.

Which Years are Safe to Buy Used?

Now that you know which years of the BMW X5 to avoid, let’s move on to models that you can probably purchase used with confidence.

  • 2016 BMW X5
  • 2017 BMW X5

The BMW X5 Model Year 2016

The 2016 BMW X5 is a safe pick for used luxury automobile buyers with a dependability rating of 4 out of 5. The 2016 X5 is a wonderful example of the X5 range, from its exceptional drive quality to its quick handling to its high-grade amenities.

There is a widespread issue with the 2016 model that most buyers don’t care about: excessive tire noise.

The BMW X5 Model Year 2017

When it comes to the 2017 X5’s dependability, Consumer Reports gives it a perfect five out of five stars.

The 2017 X5’s dependability difficulties are limited to complaints of squeaky brakes and a defective climate system. You can buy a used 2017 BMW X5 with confidence.

BMW X5 cars from 2000 and 2005 are also dependable. In general, all years are fine, but the three models listed above have the lowest number of customer complaints, the best build quality, and the most powerful engine options.


The BMW X5 is a great SUV for people seeking a balance of sportiness and elegance. Simply be cautious while purchasing some of these old model years. Ask the correct questions and arm yourself with as much information as possible. Alternatively, you may decide to get a new X5 this year.

Related Posts:

Similar Posts